Comments:
PR Ganapathy on July 20th, 2007 at 1:36 am #
Arranged marriages in India are representative of a much deeper malaise: the inability of Indian parents to trust their children to make decisions for themselves. This starts with seemingly innocuous decisions at a young age Why can’t Indian parents trust themselves that they’ve brought up their children well, given them sound judgment, and therefore let go? Young Indian adults often end up making poor decisions when they finally have to, because they haven’t been used to doing it while growing up. “Good enough parenting” is the ability to step back and let your children experience life to the full, intervening only when they are doing something that is putting their life at risk. We should all practice it a bit more to create a truly “free” generation.
Mani on July 26th, 2007 at 8:45 am #
I enjoyed the comment by Ganapathy more than the article.- which is a thought provoking one.
Vidya on July 26th, 2007 at 11:28 pm #
There is also a flip side to what you suggest, Guns. In more than one family of my acquaintance, the adult child has come back to ask his parents “Why did you let me do that? You were the adult, you should have advised me.” It is in terror of hearing the same thing from my kids that I preface most of my gyan to them with “…if you don’t want to do do it, don’t blame me later..consider yourself advised!”
Shefaly on August 2nd, 2007 at 9:48 am #
Parenting with a disclaimer! Even better than parenting that actively disables a child’s ability to make his or her own decisions. As an ‘auntie’, and an elder sister, I am finding myself more and more in situations where my advice is sought. I see my role as enabling the advice-seeker to ask all possible questions that need answering and then encouraging him/ her to reflect and decide. This is the model I was brought up with and this is the only model I know. What is interesting that youngsters, whose parents are well-educated doctors, IIMA-MBAs, surgeons etc, prefer to seek advice from a neutral party whose judgement is unlikely to be coloured by blind love and who really does not care for or fear being blamed in the future. Parents should stop and think why that is the case. I would say an adult progeny who comes back to blame parents is an ungrateful, self-centred person rather than a badly brought up child.
PR Ganapathy on August 2nd, 2007 at 2:45 pm #
Vidya, Shefaly, if I may offer some thoughts - I think there’s a problem if adults are going back to their parents and blaming them for poor decisions that they (the adults) took. Part of being able to take a decision is the ability to take responsibility for its outcomes. A parent who lets his / her children make their own decisions should not only teach them that, but also not fall for this blackmail of “you could’ve stopped me”. It’s like a Golfer blaming his caddy when he misses the putt. The caddy can suggest a line, but the Golfer has to overcome his indecisiveness and stroke the putt, and then live with the score that comes out of it.
Shefaly on August 2nd, 2007 at 2:56 pm #
Guns: Man, you have changed a lot since 1993! (I was D1, a batch after you and can cite some stuff related to Walter Raleigh as the code word…) Post a comment
|
|