Palace of Illusions – Book Review

By Vidya Pradhan

palace-of-illusions.jpgChitra Bannerjee Divakaruni has made a name for herself with her stories about the Indian immigrant experience, usually viewed through the eyes of a woman. I remember being quite impressed with Arranged Marriage and Sister of my Heart, perhaps because in those days I was a new immigrant to the US myself. Eventually, when the theme was repeated in endless variations in successive books, the attraction waned. The flowery metaphors, the effusive prose, epitomized a style of writing that was too gushy to be literary, too cloying to be entertaining.

In Palace of Illusions, CBD returns with a feminist retelling of the Mahabharata, seen through the eyes of Draupadi, one of the few polyandrous women in an age of polygamy. The great epic is surprisingly opaque about the character and motivations of the Pandava queen, given her presence at some of the most crucial moments in the narrative.

Divakaruni attempts a picturesque character study, creating a childhood and adolescence for Draupadi that follows a story arc familiar to readers of historical fiction. In fact, a book I read just prior to this one (Pope Joan) had almost the same formula – an uncertain birth, a neglected childhood and an influential but grief-ridden future foretold by a soothsayer.

To readers who have accessed the Mahabharata through Amar Chitra Kathas or C.Rajagopalachari’s excellent primer, Draupadi is known only as a victim of circumstance – first yoked to 5 brothers without her consent, then famously stripped of her sari in public. Divakaruni had the opportunity to make a stronger, more decisive, courageous character, but in her hands Draupadi is as much a prisoner of her fate as in Vyasa’s narration. Like her more famous husbands, she is pulled along by the tides of her pre-ordained destiny and remains a spectator in the escalating tension that draws the Kuru clan inexorably towards war. Her shrewish nature and hard core make it hard to feel sympathy for a character who is probably one of the most ill-treated in the complex saga of the Pandavas and Kauravas and Divakaruni’s treatment feels like a missed opportunity.

Another female character, Kunti, is also fleshed out. Kunti, in Divakaruni’s version, is almost a Machiavellian character reminiscent of the mothers-in-law from television saas-bahu soaps. It makes for an interesting, if jarring, interpretation.

Palace of Illusions is still a rollicking read, because the story rises above the style. The prolixity of the prose works, somewhat, because of its setting. The Mahabharata, after all, is not meant to be digested at a single setting. The ornamented metaphors (“Summer unfolded its drowsy petals”) seem appropriate for their environment.

The Mahabharata, which my grandmother claims is the repository of every known story in the universe, is an absorbing drama which is less about good and evil than it is about politics and strategy. It is open to a great deal of interpretation and a perfectly good case can be made for the seemingly reprehensible behavior of the Kauravas led by Duryodhana. The moral ambiguity of this epic makes it a page turner and Divakaruni manages to weave in some of the lesser known anecdotes skillfully. You may even find a nugget or two that is new to you. And just to pique your interest, let me add that there is an unexpected and totally dishy love angle for Draupadi that I have never come across in any other adaptation of one of the greatest stories ever told.

3 thoughts on “Palace of Illusions – Book Review

  1. pradip bhattacharya

    Pratibha Ray’s much awarded novel “Yajnaseni” (RUPA) is recommended reading. For understanding the psychology of Draupadi and Kunti, see my “Panchakanya–the five virgins of Indian Epics” (Writers Workshop).

    Like

    Reply
  2. Ranju

    Now you have really piqued my interest… in the same vein as the previous commenter, I recommend “Yuganta” – originally written in Marathi by Iravati Karve, and (fortunately) translated by her as well. She is simply awesome in her anthropological treatment of the Mahabharata.
    ..I *hope* that the love angle that you so tantalizingly hint at is not about Karna and Draupadi – because both Iravati Karve and Pratibha Ray (Yajnaseni) have been there, done that.

    Like

    Reply
  3. Reema Sahay

    ‘Yajnaseni’ is really an awesome book, for any enthusiast of Mahabharata. I have read both Yajnaseni as well as Yuganta, and right now reading C. Rajagopalachari’s Mahabharata. Mahabharata is truly a fascinating tale, no matter how much you read about it, you crave for more. I have researched and zeroed in on a couple of books for reading. If anybody has already read these books, please do share your reviews. Also, most of these are out-of-print, especially ‘second turn’; does anyone have any idea, where to get it from?

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s